In the chamber, Ms Gillard invariably chooses to answer "questions without notice" from the Opposition with a reminder of former government policy which is irrelevant, thus avoiding the question designed to be incisive.

When the Opposition would raise a point of order regarding the relevance of (avoiding) the answer, the former Speaker (Harry Jenkins) would rule, "the Prime Minister is responding to the question".

Yes, Mr Speaker, the PM was responding, but not answering. There is a difference.

In times most recent, perhaps we have seen "the real Julia", a lady, fragile, vulnerable, confused, shoeless and undignified by circumstance, manhandled to safety in the security car and showing compassion for the Leader of the Opposition.

The incident reverberated around the world.

Our government "may" take action, with "may" being the operative word.

The aftermath, the burning of and spitting on Australia's national flag and the command by the indigenous male, to quote, "Piss off out of our country", will be seen on television around the world and will earn the indigenous movement little support.

That an apology from an indigenous person has already been forthcoming is a saving grace.

GRAEME PHILLIPS

Moss Vale